|Photo Detective: Vintage to Vogue
By Maureen A. Taylor
For years, my mother has said that if you wait long enough, an older style will come back in vogue. Now that my daughter chooses to wear 1960s styles,
I believe her. This is one challenge of trying to interpret clothing in photographs. Styles not only resurface, but they also evolve in both subtle and
dramatic ways from year to year. Two particularly troublesome decades are the 1870s and 1880s, which actually encompassed five distinctive fashion
periods. You can still date late 19th-century photographs, though, by following these steps.
Get the facts.
Before and after examining clothing clues, it's important to review the photo's facts—that is, what you know about the picture from the
photographer's imprint, photographic method, caption and oral history. All this data provides you with a time frame for the picture.
Pay attention to details.
To date clothing, you must examine all the elements of a person's attire, such as the neckline, collar, sleeves, skirt, trim and accessories. Here are a few
key features of 1870s and 1880s fashion:
1869 to 1875
overskirts worn with a jacketlike bodice pulled over the hips
ruffles and pleats
long, flowing hair worn off the face
open-necked dresses highlighted by neck scarves
black neck ribbons with a charm or brooch attached
1876 to 1878
tight, long-waisted bodices buttoned up the front
longer overskirts, falling at the calf or lower
closed necklines with high-neck collars and trim
heavy-looking jewelry, especially long earrings and chains
false hair worn on top of the head
1879 to 1882
tight dresses with pleated trim and wide collars
bodices that button up the front
slight puffs of fabric at the hips (reminiscent of 18th-century panniers that greatly accented the hip)
some shirring in the skirt
dresses with a mix of fabrics and patterns
overskirts in a variety of sizes and shapes
hairstyles with curls worn flat on the forehead and the rest of the hair pulled tight to the head
1883 to 1888
dresses consisting of a skirt, overskirt and front-fastening bodice worn hip length
overskirts draped asymmetrically, often featuring a point in the front
a return of the bustle, which achieves its fullest form in this period
tight sleeves and high necklines accenting pleated skirts.
various fabric patterns within the same outfit
humorous jewelry, fans and parasols
1889 to 1892
narrow skirts, which are difficult to walk in
bodices with high collars
tight sleeves with small puffed shoulders
jewelry kept to a minimum, except for small pins
Compare the clues.
Developing an eye for costume details takes time and patience—especially if you're not used to looking for them. If you're not sure about the costume's
date, try comparing it to attire in books such as Dressed for the Photographer by Joan Severa (Kent State University Press, $60), Victorian Costume for
Ladies, 1860-1900 by Linda Setnick (Schiffer, $29.95) or Dating Old Photographs, 1840-1929 edited by Halvor Moorshead (Family Chronicle, $12).
The complicated 1870s and 1880s costume changes require patience to decipher. But with a little effort, you'll narrow your pictures' time frames to
within a few years. Look for more information on using costume clues to date family photographs in the August 2004 Family Tree Magazine.
ELEMENTS of STYLE
By Maureen A.Taylor
Tracking yesterday's fashion trends could solve your picture puzzles. We'll show you how to analyze your ancestors' dress for successful photo
When we think of milestones in US history, the Revolutionary War, Civil War and civil rights movement immediately come to mind. Knowing the details of
events such as these puts your ancestors into historical context. But turning points in American fashion history — for instance, the first riveted blue
jeans (1873), sunglasses (1885) and nylon stockings (1940) — matter too. Match them with clothing and accessories in old photos, and you can identify
those mystery faces.
Fashion constantly evolves, and our photographs reflect the changing styles. By examining the clothing clues in your unidentified images, you can
narrow their time frames to just a few years, and determine which relatives peer back at you. Even a single accessory could tell you whether you're
looking at your great-grandmother or your great-great-grandmother.
For example, during the 1840s, women wore daycaps (bonnets made of starched white cotton) for everyday and special occasions. By the 1850s, this
headgear had fallen out of fashion, though elderly women continued to wear them for several more decades. If you have a picture of a relative wearing
one of these hats in her youth, the image likely dates back to the 1840s. (Of course, you'll have to examine other clothing clues to be certain.) Once
you've narrowed the photo's time frame, you should consult your genealogical records to determine whether your female ancestors' ages at that time
correspond to the age of the picture's subject. With luck, you'll find a match.
You don't have to be a fashion maven to spot clothing clues in photographs. Just follow these identification tips and our 19th-century fashion-trend
timelines, and you'll be putting names to those mystery faces in no time.
Begin by enlarging segments of an unidentified picture with a magnifying glass or by scanning it. Examine every detail of the subject's outfit. Look at the
shape of a woman's bodice, neckline, sleeves and skirt — and don't forget accessories and hairstyle. Pay attention to a man's coat shape, trouser
width, necktie style, hairstyle and accessories. Any of these details could clue you in to when the photo was taken. Of course, shoe styles have
changed, too, but they're usually difficult to distinguish in old photos.
Most family portraits show relatives dressed in their “best.” In the 19th century, popular magazines such as Godey's Lady's Book advised women on
what to wear. But if your ancestor lacked the latest accessory, some studios kept shawls, pins and hats on hand for patrons to borrow. After all, a happy
customer meant repeat business and referrals.
Our ancestors' economic circumstances did influence their clothing choices, but style variations between classes usually aren't significant. Women who
lacked financial resources or lived in rural areas still followed fashion trends — they would remake dresses or add a few accessories to fit the current
You'll find more-significant style variations in portraits of recent immigrants or ancestors living in foreign countries. These differences actually could
simplify the identification process, though. For instance, a headdress worn for a wedding photo could tell you whether the image comes from your
Russian mother's side or your Scottish father's side of the family.
Dating a photograph through costume requires some knowledge of fashion history — and that's easy to get. Here, we identify key components of 19th-
century fashion since the advent of photography, decade by decade, so you can start solving even your toughest picture puzzles now.
What women wore
Women's fashion has changed dramatically through the years, so even the length of a skirt or the shape of a sleeve can help you date an image.
Accessories such as gloves, jewelry, hats and fans have fallen in and out of fashion, which means they can aid identification, too.
The basic elements of our female ancestors' clothing remained the same regardless of their economic status. Pants weren't popular until the mid-1900s,
so women typically wore dresses. Frugal women often pieced together two or more dresses to create an outfit reflecting current styles. Be on the
lookout for dresses with bodices and skirts made of different materials.
Before drawing conclusions about your photographs, be sure to add up all the clues, rather than focusing on a single style detail. When in doubt, make
a list of an outfit's significant characteristics. Look not only at the shape of a sleeve, but also the width of the cuff. Since most women made their own
clothes until the 20th century, you will see some style variation. But watch out for these common elements:
1840 to 1849:
The first photographs, known as daguerreotypes, appeared in the United States in 1840. Throughout the next decade, a resurgence in religious and
moral conservatism led women to dress in modest, restrictive clothes, which often inhibited natural movement, according to Dressed for the
Photographer by Joan Severa. Worn over corsets, back-fastening dresses had long, tight bodices with fan-shaped gatherings. The wide, shallow,
horizontal necklines gradually narrowed later in the decade, when high-standing collars came into vogue. Sleeves were long and tight, especially on the
upper arms. Popular accessories included fingerless gloves, gold watches on long chains, ribbon bracelets and bonnets that extended past the chin.
Women wore their hair close to the head, with a center part, long ringlets and large combs.
1850 to 1859:
Women's fashion loosened up a bit in the 1850s, and ladies' magazines such as Godey's increasingly reported on the trends. Dress sleeves were still
narrow at the shoulder, but flared at the wrist, revealing white undersleeves. Our ancestors fashioned full, gathered or pleated skirts over hoops, and
favored dresses with more trim and color. Women parted their hair in the center and let it droop over their ears. They also experimented with
ornamental hair jewelry, and wore bonnets off the face and tied with wide ribbon. By mid-decade, front-fastening bodices with broad collars gained
popularity. At the end of the 1850s, collars narrowed, and sleeves gathered at the wrist once again.
1860 to 1868:
During the Civil War, women selected bodices that buttoned down the front and had pointed or round waists decorated with military braid. Most dresses
featured high, narrow, round collars, but some had V-necks with lapels. Sleeve styles varied: Some came in at the wrist, and others flared. Skirts worn
over hoops were pleated, and some looped up (with assistance of cords on the inside of the skirt) to expose underskirts. Women accessorized with
shawls, hairnets, wide belts, elaborate earrings and brooches. They wore their hair with a center part and covering their ears. Some opted for braids or
short ringlets. Bonnets changed shape from round to oval early in the decade. As hairstyles became more elaborate after the war, women sported
1869 to 1874:
Ruffles were all the rage during this era: Bodices featured ruffles and large, prominent buttons; necklines were high with low-standing collars, or V-necks
with ruffles; and some moderately bell-shaped coat sleeves had ruffles. Skirts were trimmed with apron-like overskirts, and bustles — some quite large
— expanded underskirts. Accessories included black velvet neck ribbons with brooches or charms attached to the front, large lockets on gold chains,
crosses, and long jet-bead necklaces with matching earrings. Women continued to part their hair in the center, and began to wear false locks with large
combs. They often braided their hair at the crown and left the rest streaming down their backs. Small hats and bonnets trimmed with feathers, lace and
flowers accented these high, full hairstyles.
1857 to 1877:
During the mid-1870s, waistlines lengthened, and two-piece dresses gained popularity. Front-opening necklines featured low collars or V-necks with
ruffles. Sleeves were narrower and decorated with trim. Skirts began to lose their fullness, and had long overskirts and trains.
1878 to 1882:
By the late 1870s, the full hoop skirt had gone out of style, and the bustle disappeared. Skirts now fell straight from hip to floor. Front buttons adorned
tight-fitting bodices, which came down over the hips. Necklines were high with low-standing collars, and sleeves remained narrow. Women continued to
part their hair in the center, and wore short, frizzed bangs.
1883 to 1889:
By the mid-1880s, women had entered the work force as secretaries, telephone operators and department-store clerks, and demanded less-restrictive
clothing. Draped overskirts, often apronlike in shape, appeared. The bustle returned in 1883 and reached its maximum size in 1886, before deflating the
next year. Tight bodices extended below the waist, and had high necklines with low-standing collars. Tight, three-quarter-length sleeves with trim at the
wrist also were popular. Look for lace parasols, muffs and novelty jewelry. Hair remained frizzed around the face with a bun in back. Women chose hats
in a variety of styles, the most popular being high-crowned hats with wide brims and elaborate trim.
1890 to 1900:
The demand for less-restrictive clothing increased as women began to exercise outdoors. As a result, corsets loosened, and shirtwaists came into
vogue. Necklines had high collars worn to the chin. In the early 1890s, women wore large, balloon-like “leg-o-mutton” sleeves that were tight at the wrist.
After 1896, sleeves got smaller, with fullness at the shoulder and a slight flare over the hand. Skirts were smooth at the hips, but flared dramatically.
Between 1893 and 1896, women favored feather boas, large fans and parasols. At the end of the decade, they accessorized with small earrings,
watches pinned to their bosoms, and small decorative combs worn high on the back of the head, but visible from the front. Short bangs, worn with a
small topknot, remained popular during the first part of the decade, but went out of style by 1896. Then, women parted and flattened their hair into
waves along the temples. Although older women still sported bonnets, most young women had switched to hats, especially small hats with vertical trim.
By the end of the decade, wide-brimmed hats also were popular.
Clothes make the man
Men's clothing is harder to date because style varied little in the 19th century. Their dress clothes comprised a coat, shirt, trousers, necktie and possibly
a vest. Work attire consisted of a collarless shirt, no tie, pants, suspenders and sometimes a vest. The best clothing clues are hats, vests and shirts, as
these garments changed the most over time. You'll have to look closely for subtle clues.
1840 to 1849:
During this decade, men wore coats with extra-long, narrow sleeves; tailored white shirts with narrow sleeves and small turned-up collars; and dark-
colored neckties in horizontal bowknots. Smocklike work shirts came in a variety of colors and patterns. Men kept their hair at ear length and parted high
on one side. Most were clean-shaven, but some sported fringe beards that framed their jaws. Hat styles included wool stocking caps, black felt bowlers
and shiny silk top hats.
1850 to 1859:
Narrow sleeves remained stylish into the first part of the 1850s. Around 1854, generously cut suit coats (worn with vests) and wide-legged pants came
into vogue. Shirt collars turned over 2-inch-wide neckties, worn in wide half-bows. Men wore dress shirts in a variety of colors and patterns. They also
bought fancy starched shirtfronts to dress up their attire. Most men were clean-shaven until the end of the decade, when full beards appeared. They
wore their oiled hair long on top and combed into a wave at the center of the forehead. Later in the decade, their hair grew long enough to cover the
ears. Young men wore cloth caps, which resembled railroad caps. Tall black hats with flat brims also gained popularity.
1860 to 1869:
Men's suit coats came in a range of new shapes in the 1860s — the most popular being the long, oversized sack coat, worn with wide-legged pants that
were longer at the heel and held up by suspenders. A white, striped or plaid shirt and narrow necktie completed the look. Men parted their ear-length
hair on the side and grew whiskers, rather than full beards. After the Civil War, they continued to wear military caps to work.
1870 to 1879:
The popular sack coat got shorter and narrower during this decade, and buttoned only at the top in order to display the vest and watch chain worn
underneath. White, striped and plaid shirts were made without collars — our ancestors bought those separately. They wore wide black or striped
neckties in loose knots with overlapping ends. Fur hats and coats also gained popularity at this time.
1880 to 1889:
In the 1880s, men's coats got even shorter and narrower, and they closed high at the throat, nearly concealing the necktie. Our ancestors wore these
coats with narrow, creaseless pants and wide shirts. Neckties varied in width. Throughout the decade, young men sported a wide variety of hats, from
straw sailor hats to black homburgs (felt hats featuring dented crowns and shallow, rolled brims), which businessmen favored.
1890 to 1900:
Narrow was the key characteristic of 1890s men's fashion: narrow coats worn buttoned to the top, narrow black or patterned bow ties and narrow
trousers. White shirts had small, stiff, pointed collars at the beginning of the decade and high, stiff collars at the end of the decade. Men wore their hair
short and grew large mustaches. Bowlers and derby-style hats' popularity exploded during this decade.
In the 19th and early 20th centuries, babies of both sexes wore long dresses; current adult fashion trends dictated the gowns' lengths and details.
Toddlers sported shorter dresses to accommodate movement. The best way to tell girls and boys apart is to look at their hairstyles. Girls usually wore
their hair parted in the middle, and boys' hair was parted on the side.
Parents dressed their older sons in short pants and their daughters in dresses. Children's fashion generally followed the same trends as adults'. As
children grew older, their clothing styles changed — which enables you to estimate a child's age based on his or her clothing. For instance, the length of
a girl's skirt gradually got longer as she approached adulthood. Boys wore short pants until approximately age 12, then donned long pants.
Frances Hodgson Burnett started a fashion trend for boys when her book Little Lord Fauntleroy was published in 1886. Until the early 20th century,
mothers dressed their sons in outfits that mimicked those in the book's drawings by Reginald Birch. A typical outfit consisted of a white shirt with a full
Vandyke collar (a large linen or lace collar with a scalloped edge), a satin sash, a plumed hat and long, curled hair.
All in the details
Not only can clothing help you date an image, but it also can clue you in to your ancestors' experiences. Keep an eye out for these telling details:
• Traditional ethnic dress: Upon arriving in America, immigrants often abandoned their full ethnic dress so they could better assimilate. But occasionally,
accessories such as caps, head scarves and mantillas will identify their ethnicity. Robert Harrold's Folk Costumes of the World (Sterling Publishing Co.)
offers an overview of clothing styles around the globe.
• Fraternal-order regalia: You might find photographic evidence of an ancestor's membership in a fraternal order, such as the Freemasons, Modern
Woodmen of America or Elks. Medals, buttons, ribbons, badges, sashes and jewelry (including watches, fobs, pins and rings) could contain symbols and
slogans of one of these organizations. For tips on researching fraternal orders, see the June 2004 Family Tree Magazine.
• Military uniforms: Studying headgear, buttons, shirts, pants, weapons and decoration can date a photograph and provide evidence of military service.
For instance, during the Civil War, many Union volunteers wore belt buckles with their states' abbreviations; Confederate soldiers wore buckles with the
letters CSA, which stood for Confederate States of America. If you're trying to trace Civil War ancestors, those belt buckles could give you enough clues
to locate military records.
• Occupational clothing: Look for hats, aprons or props suggesting your ancestor's employment. Consult Dressed for the Job by Christobel Williams-
Mitchell (Blandford Books) for pictures of people on the job.
• Religious attire: Photos of altar boys, priests, nuns and other people in religious garb can be difficult to date because the clothing styles don't change.
But these portraits can provide clues about your ancestors' religious affiliation. Look for Bibles, candles, flowers and other religious symbols.
As you add up all the costume clues in your photographs, remember: Looks can be deceiving. Just because your ancestor's outfit seems to date to the
1880s, that doesn't mean it actually does. For example, in some tourist spots, you can have your picture taken in period clothing. One of my friends has
a tintype of himself in a Civil War uniform. Not only did the photographer copy the 19th-century photographic process, but the clothing looks authentic.
To an unsuspecting descendant, this photo might appear older than it actually is.
It's easy to misidentify both the person and the time period if you look only at costume clues. Wedding pictures, for instance, can offer conflicting
evidence if the bride wears an heirloom gown. So be sure to look for other hints, such as props, before drawing a conclusion.
Once you've used costume clues to estimate a picture's time frame, consult magazines and store catalogs from that period, or flip through books with
historical photos to confirm your analysis. If you're still having trouble placing the photograph within a fashion context, you might want to consult a
costume professional. Some historical societies and museums have staff who specialize in costume history.
Over the years, I've developed a fascination with historical fashion. The clothing provides glimpses into our ancestors' everyday lives and insights into
their personalities. The next time you pose for a picture, think about what you're wearing — and what those clothes will say to your descendants.
From the September 2004 Trace Your Family History.